We use cookies and other similar technologies (Cookies) to enhance your experience and to provide you with relevant content and ads. By using our website, you are agreeing to the use of Cookies. You can change your settings at any time. Cookie Policy.

Telecom Business Intelligence: The Five Forces of a Highly Competitive Industry

Originally published July 26, 2005

VoIP. VoIP. VoIP. Thanks for Vonage’s imaginative television commercials and Skype’s robust, and free, desktop client; Voice over Internet Protocol, VoIP, is all the rage for the telecom service providers and equipment manufacturers. Everyone wants to get on the VoIP bandwagon.

And no wonder. A recent TeleGeograpy Study shows that residential subscriber levels in the United States are projected to jump from only 150,000 in 2003 to over 4 million by the end of 2005. The same study predicts that the same residential VoIP market should reach $1 billion in gross revenues this year. Worldwide VoIP usage, including wholesale, retail consumer and retail business, are projected to top 2.4 trillion minutes. Not too bad for a concept that was not in a realized form, let alone a definable industry, until 1995.

VoIP represents a great opportunity for telecom service providers to develop flexible and responsive offerings. These services can be developed as premium services by fully using the strengths of the Internet or internal intranets. These services can also be developed to exploit efficiencies that the Internet and intranets offer that traditional networks and network providers do not. However, it is not all peaches and cream. While current and potential telecom service providers can build imaginative offerings and business plans; they must still be mindful of the competitive environment surrounding the VoIP market.

Forces and Trends

In a recent TelecomDirect News article, I read about the key trends for VoIP in 2005. As I read through the list, it brought me back to the “star” of last month’s article, Michael Porter. If you remember, Porter is one of the preeminent experts in the field of competitive strategies. In 1980, he set out a framework for strategic business managers to assess the overall competitive environment of, and thus the risks associated with, a particular industry. This framework has become known as the "five forces model.” The “five forces” describe threats to a company’s competitive advantage in an industry. Here is a breakdown of the "five forces model:”

  1. Degree of rivalry of existing industry competitors.
  2. Degree of barriers to entry by new competitors in the industry.
  3. Threat of substitute products/services.
  4. Bargaining power of buyers.
  5. Bargaining power of suppliers.

Below are five areas that exemplify the concepts of the “five forces” and show how trends can really be pressures on an organization’s competitive nature:

  • Industry Consolidation: As we have seen in the wireless / cellular service provider market, this can mean threats from existing companies who consolidate their position and acquire additional market share by purchasing their competition (Rivalry).
  • Wireless Local-Area Networks: The Internet and broadband-based VoIP market could soon face competitors from the wireless / cellular service providers (Substitutes) via wireless local area networks, WLANs.
  • Security/Fraud: When you think about using a free VoIP service, like Skype, you do not necessarily think about fraud. However, when you start looking at the pay VoIP services, fraud becomes a much larger issue. Carolyn Schuk has written an excellent article on VoIP Fraud detailing these issues (Barriers to Entry).
  • Pricing: Wireless / cellular and traditional phone service providers have seen demands from consumer’s drive their price per minute via lower tiered minute and flat rate plans. Pay VoIP providers are entering not at the top, but closer to the bottom of these pricing levels (Buyers).
  • Broadband Access: The penetration rate of broadband access in the United States, the lifeblood of pay VoIP services, is around 55 to 60 percent. This effectively caps the number of customers that have access to VoIP services and places more power in the hands of the broadband access providers (Suppliers).

These conditions create a highly competitive environment particularly for the pay VoIP market. However, in this highly lucrative industry; telecom service providers need to create a competitive advantage to become or stay successful. Last month we talked about the three different strategies to create that competitive advantage as defined by Porter. This month, we will look at the two primary strategies and how data warehousing and business intelligence can enable the success of telecom service providers in this market.

Low-Cost Provider

As a low-cost provider, telecom service providers looking to build a business model for the pay VoIP services market need to focus on lowering their costs relative to the rest of the industry. This can mean everything from low overheads to open source applications (ex. Asterisk - the Open Source PBX). However, if you read Carolyn Schuk’s article on VoIP fraud, the highest potential internal cost is fraud and the costs associated with fraud. Schuk’s article brings to mind visions of Tony Soprano figuring out from month to month different avenues to make money from telecom fraud. The threat of monetary, legal and bankruptcy costs all represent a barrier to entry for firms wishing to enter the pay VoIP services market.

How can data warehouses and business intelligence prevent this type of fraud and thus lower this competitive threat? With the increasing amounts of VoIP traffic, the key will be effective monitoring and analysis of a telecom service provider’s customer usage event information. Unfortunately, with the “stateless” nature, literally and figuratively, of VoIP traffic; the key will be to migrate the information from the network to an analytical environment as close to real-time as possible.

I’m not going to tell you that real-time, or near real-time, analysis will prevent the Tony Soprano’s of the world from creating new and inventive ways of committing acts of fraud. However, as the time between actual service usage event, and evidence of that usage event arrives in an analytical environment is lowered; fraud detection organizations will have a much better chance to minimize the cost associated with that fraud. Also, the standard processes to determine and report that evidence of fraud should enable legal remedies for recovery of the costs associated with fraud.

Premium Provider

Telecom service providers looking to position themselves as a premium provider of pay VoIP services must focus on their quality of service. If a telecom service provider is going to charge similar prices to existing landline and wireless service providers, those providers need to focus on providing the best quality connections possible. This is an area where the threat of substitutes creates a competitive pressure on the pay VoIP service providers. Despite what I heard from the CEO of a Regional Bell Operating Company last year about the limited importance of quality of service relating to VoIP calls, it is a critical aspect of being a premium provider.

If you are using the Skype client for free to contact friends and family to “avoid” long distance charges, you can handle a certain amount of echo, delay and downtime. You have lower expectations of a free service. However, if you are a residential subscriber paying both a VoIP service provider like Vonage AND a broadband provider like Comcast, you have much higher expectations. You expect the quality of service to be predictable, because a wireless or landline phone can do the same thing for approximately the same price or less. 

VoIP quality of service can be a tricky thing since it relates mostly to the capacity and traffic on a given network segment or a series of network segments. Most pay VoIP service providers, especially for residential subscribers, do not own the networks that they pass traffic across. For these organizations, data warehouse and business intelligence can enable competitive advantage again via the monitoring of usage event data. Ensuring that network service level agreements, or SLAs, are met can prevent poor connection experiences for their business and residential customers.

For the data warehouse and business intelligence environments, data mining and statistical analysis applications are looking more for areas of poor network performance instead of fraudulent usage. This is a much more easily defined activity. Despite the relative “ease” of finding “slow” or “stopped” network segments, the timeliness of the data is just as critical for auditing of network service level agreements for telecom service providers positioning themselves as premium providers as it is for their low-cost counterparts. This results in the need to identify those problem areas and make arrangements for other network routes in the short-term and other network partners in the long run.

Practice Makes Perfect

Both of the above examples of enabling the competitive advantage of telecom service providers can be taken as one time events by analyzing transactional data. But to get the most out of fraud detection and quality of service assurance, telecom service providers need to get their data warehouse and business intelligence groups involved in creating repeatable processes, not just a one time project. And, those data warehouse and business intelligence groups need to step up and provide timely, if not near real-time, and accurate information to enable the telecom service provider to maintain its position as either a low-cost or premium service provider.

  • John MyersJohn Myers

    John Myers, a senior analyst in the business intelligence (BI) practice at  Enterprise Management Associates (EMA). In this role, John delivers comprehensive coverage of the business intelligence and data warehouse industry with a focus on database management, data integration, data visualization, and process management solutions. Prior to joining EMA, John spent over ten years working with business analytics implementations associated with the telecommunications industry.

    John may be contacted by email at JMyers@enterprisemanagement.com.

    Editor's note: More telecom articles, resources, news and events are available in the BeyeNETWORK's Telecom Channel. Be sure to visit today!

Recent articles by John Myers



Want to post a comment? Login or become a member today!

Posted September 13, 2012 by Anonymous

VoIP represents a great opportunity.


Wildblue offers, fast, reliable,  satellite internet service  wherever you live.

Is this comment inappropriate? Click here to flag this comment.

Posted May 12, 2012 by Anonymous

I wonder why other professionals don’t notice your website much m glad I found this.

learn more about wildblue

Is this comment inappropriate? Click here to flag this comment.

Posted May 12, 2012 by mary brown

What a great post! I really enjoyed reading this. Thank you for sharing this valuable information with us. I have bookmarked this site and will be sure to check for updates.

Exede satellite Internet service

Is this comment inappropriate? Click here to flag this comment.